Introduction
...
Four tables are presented below, one table for quality issues that are common to both community generated and curated datasets, the second table for dataset quality issues unique to community generated datasets, the third table for dataset quality issues unique to curated datasets and the fourth table lists the potential data quality issues that are checked as part of the HDX Quality Assurance Framework (QAF).
A mindmap graphic visualizes these issues:
Table 1. Common Dataset Quality Assurance
...
Procedures
ID | Potential Quality Issue | When to check | How to check | Corrective action |
101 | Unrelated item in related items tab | -When a related item is added | Using a script, identify datasets with a related item and evaluate the related item for relevance | Delete related item Engage responsible user |
102 | Dataset metadata missing or incomplete | -When dataset is made public -When dataset is revised -During routine data QA process | Manual or scripted evaluation of the dataset | Engage org admin |
...
ID | Potential Quality Issue | When to check | How to check | Corrective action |
201 | Dataset has no resources (files or links) | -When dataset is made public -During routine data QA process | Manual or scripted count of the number of resources in the dataset | Make dataset private Engage org admin |
202 | Dataset has a broken resource link | -When dataset is made public -During routine data QA process | Manual or scripted check of resource link | Engage org admin Check for 201 |
203 | Dataset contains no relevant humanitarian data | -When dataset is made public | Manual evaluation of the data | Make dataset private Engage org admin |
204 | Dataset contains test data | -When dataset is made public | Manual evaluation of the data | Make dataset private Engage org admin |
205 | Dataset contains sensitive data (PII, DII, CII) | -When dataset is made public | Manual evaluation of the data | Make dataset private/ Remove dataset from platform Engage org admin Refer for management review |
206 | Dataset contains inappropriate or otherwise objectionable content | -When dataset is made public | Manual evaluation of the data | Make dataset private Revoke user editing privileges Refer for management review Engage org admin |
| 207 | Dataset contains the COD tag | -When dataset is made public | Manual or scripted check for the COD tag in the data | Remove the tag Engage the data provider |
| 208 | Dataset contains individual survey data | -When dataset is made public | Manual evaluation of the data, special check for PII, DII or CII Look for data dictionary | Make dataset private Engage the data provider |
| 209 | Dataset contains a PDF resource that is not considered metadata | -When dataset is made public | Manual or scripted check for PDF document | Remove PDF or make dataset private if dataset no longer viable Engage data provider |
| 210 | Dataset source is non existent or unclear | -When dataset is made public | Manual evaluation of the dataset | Make private Engage data provider |
Table 3. Quality Assurance Procedures (for Curated Datasets)
...
ID
...
Potential Quality Issue
...
When to check
...
How to check
...
Corrective action
...
301
...
No data in XLXS/CSV file of curated indicator centric dataset
...
-When the curated data for the affected indicator is known to have been updated
-During routine data QA process
...
Manual or scripted check for data on each affected indicator centric dataset
...
Make the dataset private
Investigate data and take appropriate action
...
302
...
No data in XLXS/CSV file of curated country centric dataset
...
-When the curated data for ANY baseline/fts/rw etc indicator is known to have been updated
-During routine data QA process
...
Manual or scripted check for data on each affected country centric dataset
...
Make the dataset private
Investigate data and take appropriate action
...
303
...
All observations in XLXS/CSV file of curated indicator or country centric dataset are zero valued (Similar to no data)
...
-When the curated data for ANY baseline/fts/rw etc indicator is known to have been updated
-During routine data QA process
...
Manual or scripted check for at least one non-zero observation on each affected indicator or country centric dataset
...
Make the dataset private
Investigate data and take appropriate action
...
304
...
Missing indicator centric dataset (may have been deleted or hidden)
...
-When the curated data for ANY baseline/fts/rw etc indicator is known to have been updated
-During routine data QA process
...
Manual or scripted comparison of list of indicators that have curated data with list of indicator centric datasets
...
Create the missing indicator centric dataset or make public if dataset was private
...
305
...
Missing country centric dataset (may have been deleted or hidden)
...
-When a curated data update is made where it is possible that data has become available for a country where that data was not previously available
...
Manual or scripted comparison of the countries listed in the indicator centric dataset data and the country centric datasets for the baseline/fts/rw files
...
Create the missing country centric dataset or make public if dataset was private
...
306
...
Missing indicator in XLXS/CSV file of curated baseline/fts/rw country centric dataset
...
-When a new indicator (baseline/fts/rw etc) is curated
-During routine data QA process
...
Manual or scripted identification of the use of each indicator that has data in at least one country centric baseline/rw/fts dataset
...
Refer to development team
...
307
...
Spelling error
...
-When dataset made public
-When dataset revised
...
Manual evaluation of the dataset
...
Correct identified spelling error
...
308
...
Missing sub-national data from country centric dataset
...
-During routine data QA process
...
Manual evaluation of the dataset
...
Refer to development team
Table 4. Quality Assurance Procedures (HDX QAF)
ID | Potential Quality Issue | When to check | How to check | Corrective action |
401 | Dataset contains data that is out of range (affects accuracy) | -Before importing curated data | Automatic checking against pre-defined range for the data series | Investigate data and take appropriate action |
402 | Dataset contains data that changes dramatically from period to period (affects accuracy) | -Before importing curated data | Check data for significant period to period changes | Investigate data and take appropriate action |
403 | Dataset contains with an unexpected data type (affects accuracy) | -Before importing curated data | Automatic checking against the pre-defined data type for the data series | Investigate data and take appropriate action |
404 | Dataset contains data that participates in a part/whole relationship and the sum of the parts do not add up to the whole (affects accuracy) | -Before importing the curated data | Automatic checking for variations in values of indicators participating in part/whole relationship by adding up the parts and comparing to the whole | Investigate data and take appropriate action |
405 | Dataset contains data that is inconsistent among different sources (affects comparability) | -During the curation decision making process | Manual comparison of data series from different sources | Investigate data and take appropriate action |
406 | Dataset contains data that is sparse/incomplete (affects accuracy) | -Before importing the curated data | Automatic checking of the number of observations contained in the data against an expected number of observations for the data series | Investigate data and take appropriate action |
407 | Dataset contains a data series that is a duplication of another data series (affects accuracy) | -Before importing the curated data | Automatic checking for data series with correlations close to unity | Investigate data and take appropriate action |
408 | Dataset contains outdated data (affects timeliness) | -During routine data QA process | Compare the dataset date of the observations in the data series with the latest data from the source | Update the data |
409 | Dataset contains data that is not relevant for humanitarians (affects relevance) | -During the curation decision making process | Check if the indicator has been defined in the Common Humanitarian Dataset | Remove the data |
410 | Dataset contains data without metadata (affects interpretability) | - During routine data QA process | Check that all fields for the predefined metadata are fulfilled | Set dataset to private until metadata is completed |
411 | Dataset contains data hard to get (affects accessibility) | -During the curation decision making process | The importing process is lengthy | Develop an API or automated process |